Pillivuyt French Dinnerware vs Budget Target Dinnerware
Last winter, I discovered Target was selling a dinnerware set that looked nearly identical to the Pillivuyt French dinnerware I had previously purchased from Williams Sonoma. I shared my recent discovery on Instagram, and have since noticed many people have scooped up the Target set. I’ve also received some questions about how they compare, so I decided to share a firsthand comparison. Click through for a price breakdown, my thoughts & observations, a closer look at each set, and a detailed side-by-side comparison!
I first shared the budget beaded dinnerware set back in January, in this post: 15 Best Home Decor Finds from Target for 2024. I stumbled upon porcelain serveware that seemed like a close match to my current dishes, and decided to give it a try. Scroll on for a closer look…
My Williams Sonoma Pillivuyt Dinnerware
I splurged for the Pillivuyt beaded salad and dinnerware plates from Williams Sonoma 5-6 years ago, and have been so happy with them! These high-fired porcelain plates are made in France, are microwavable, oven safe, freezer safe, and are also dishwasher safe. Pillivuyt is a French producer of fine porcelain tableware since 1818. Their beaded dinnerware is incredibly durable and also has an elegant aesthetic- which makes it the perfect choice for both everyday meals and special occasions.
Target’s Porcelain Beaded Rim Dinnerware
When strolling the aisles of Target one day, I stumbled across these Pillivuyt-esque plates, bowls, and serveware… but for a fraction of the price. They’re also made of durable porcelain, are microwave safe, dishwasher safe, and are great for everyday use. I also noticed the Target versions are very similar in shape and size.
Size & Price Comparison
The biggest aesthetic difference is the beading size and placement. The Pillivuyt plates (top) have more pronounced beading, which is situated at the edge of the plate. The Target plates (bottom) have smaller, subtle beading, which is fixed an inch or two from the edge.
Click directly on each dish below to be redirected.
What do you think? Would you save or splurge on these porcelain dinnerware options? I think both have a very timeless look.
One is made in France, one is made in China, both are made from an obviously durable material- porcelain. See the bottom stamps on each, above…
My Thoughts & Observations
While the price is vastly different, I do think both are great options. Here are my quick thoughts and observations:
- The Pillivuyt set feels slightly heavier or more substantial.
- The Target set seems to be a true white, while the Pillivuyt set appears a bit cooler.
- Some of the Target plates have a center “lump” or imperfection in the center of the plate, whereas the Pillivuyt plates are totally flat (top notch craftsmanship).
- I prefer the deeper inset beaded edge of the Pillivuyt set.
- When stacked, the Target salad plate covers the beaded edge of the dinner plate… I think the Pillivuyt set looks nicer when styled on a table.
- The plate edge of the Target set limits space for food, making the Pillivuyt set feel larger in terms of usable space.
- I prefer the look of the Target bowls (with a small pedestal base) to the Pillivuyt bowls.
- I prefer the look of the Pillivuyt coffee mugs to the Target coffee cups.
FAQ
Without having used them for many years, it’s tough to say. Porcelain is incredibly durable, so I expect they’d wear well. Do they have the reputation that Pillivuyt has? No, but for the price- I think it’s worth a shot. I’d feel comfortable investing in a set.
Absolutely! In fact- that’s exactly what I did. My salad and dinner plates are Pillivuyt, and I ended up grabbing the bowls, serving trays, and condiment cups from Target. They match so well and the price made sense.
I did, but the stock was extremely low. I ended up ordering the rest of what I needed online.
Related
Looking for more kitchen related, budget, or designer comparison posts? I’ll link some of my favorites product reviews and curations for you below…
- An Honest Review of the GE Cafe Range (spoiler- it’s not a good one!)
- Best Designer Home Decor Dupes for 2024
- 50 Classic Kitchen Essentials from Amazon
- Grandeur vs Emtek Exterior Door Hardware
- My Dishes, Glassware, & Kitchenware
- 15 Best Home Decor Finds from Target for 2024
- 10 Surprising Home Finds from Amazon
I hope you liked this post! I always think it’s fun to compare designer dupes or find a look for less. In fact, I share more of these in my High / Low Series… be sure to check that out. I’m super curious to hear which set you’d choose? I honestly love both- which is why I currently have a mismatched set. It adds variety and fits the budget. I think it works (aesthetically) though! Let me know if you’re on the hunt for a designer look for less- I’d be happy to help search. Check back on Friday for an update on our next big outdoor project… I’ll be talking about our outdoor kitchen design plan, which I’m so excited about! Nothing like a spontaneous project.